A firework goes off in a footballer’s bathroom. The following afternoon, he scores at Old Trafford and lifts his shirt to reveal three words.
WHY ALWAYS ME?
If you were going to write that weekend for anyone, you would write it for Mario Balotelli.
On October 23, 2011, Manchester City beat Manchester United 6–1 at Old Trafford. Balotelli scored twice, but the image that survived was the Italian standing with his sky-blue shirt pulled up, letting the question underneath do the talking.
The Mario Balotelli “Why Always Me?” story has everything football folklore needs. An absurd incident at home, a derby goal, a kitman with access to a printing machine, and a player who could make a goal celebration feel like a press conference.
There is also a detail that makes the story better. The shirt was already planned before the fireworks went off.
The Fireworks Incident Before the Manchester Derby
In the early hours of October 22, a firework sparked a bathroom fire at Balotelli’s Cheshire home. He escaped unhurt.
By Sunday, the incident had become part of the buildup to the biggest game in Manchester. Imagine being a City supporter reading that news with a derby at Old Trafford coming up. Your striker’s preparation was suddenly a national talking point.
Balotelli later disputed the version that made him responsible. Speaking through City’s website, he said the incident involved friends and insisted he had done nothing. Whatever people made of his explanation, the fire itself had given the press another Balotelli story on the eve of the derby.
Sources — BBC reporting on the fire and Balotelli’s explanation to Manchester City
Who Made Balotelli’s Why Always Me Shirt?
Manchester City kitman Les Chapman printed the message. According to Chapman’s later account, Balotelli approached him on the Monday before the match and asked for something to go on his compression shirt.
Chapman ruled out anything offensive or controversial. A couple of suggestions failed that test. Then Balotelli came up with “Why always me?”
That timing matters. The conversation took place days before the bathroom fire. The slogan was already waiting for its moment when the weekend’s headlines arrived.
You can see why the two events became inseparable in people’s memories. A footballer spends Saturday in the news because of fireworks at his house, then scores on Sunday with a question about why he gets so much attention. The sequence almost edits itself.
Sources — Manchester City’s account of Chapman’s recollection and the Premier League’s shirt story
The Goal That Gave the Phrase Its Stage
In the 22nd minute at Old Trafford, James Milner found Balotelli, who guided a low finish beyond David de Gea.
Then came the pause.
Balotelli stood and revealed the shirt. There was something wonderfully direct about it. Thousands of people in the ground, television cameras fixed on him, and a question printed across his chest for everyone to read.
The match kept getting worse for United. Jonny Evans was sent off after fouling Balotelli early in the second half. Balotelli added his second, Sergio Agüero scored, and a late City surge turned a derby defeat into a 6–1 humiliation.
Edin Džeko finished with two goals and David Silva scored the other. City supporters had a scoreline they would repeat for years. Balotelli had supplied its defining photograph.
Sources — Manchester City’s retrospective on the 6–1 derby and UEFA’s match report
What Did Why Always Me Mean?
Immediately after the match, Balotelli left room for interpretation. He told City’s website there were several reasons behind the message and invited people to work it out themselves.
He was more specific about the supporters. He thanked City fans for backing him through difficult moments and described his two goals at Old Trafford as his way of repaying them. He also said the shirt message was a one-off because repeating it would mean getting booked every week.
That mix is what makes the celebration worth remembering. There was the joke, the frustration with being a constant subject of attention, and the confidence required to carry a prepared message into an away derby.
He still had to score before anyone could see it.
Source — Balotelli’s post-match comments
Why Football Still Remembers It
Plenty of players have revealed messages beneath their shirts. Balotelli gave his an audience at exactly the right moment.
For United supporters, that sky-blue kit belongs to an afternoon they would rather forget. For City supporters, it brings back the away end, the growing disbelief, and the pleasure of watching the scoreboard become increasingly ridiculous.
For everyone else, there is Mario, standing still while the rest of football tries to explain him.
Three words. One derby. Enough material for years of pub conversations.
Read more football stories from Saturdays Football
Mario Balotelli and the Crazy Story Behind Why Always Me?
A firework goes off in a footballer’s bathroom. The following afternoon, he scores at Old Trafford and lifts his shirt to reveal three words.
WHY ALWAYS ME?
If you were going to write that weekend for anyone, you would write it for Mario Balotelli.
On October 23, 2011, Manchester City beat Manchester United 6–1 at Old Trafford. Balotelli scored twice, but the image that survived was the Italian standing with his sky-blue shirt pulled up, letting the question underneath do the talking.
The Mario Balotelli “Why Always Me?” story has everything football folklore needs. An absurd incident at home, a derby goal, a kitman with access to a printing machine, and a player who could make a goal celebration feel like a press conference.
There is also a detail that makes the story better. The shirt was already planned before the fireworks went off.
The Fireworks Incident Before the Manchester Derby
In the early hours of October 22, a firework sparked a bathroom fire at Balotelli’s Cheshire home. He escaped unhurt.
By Sunday, the incident had become part of the buildup to the biggest game in Manchester. Imagine being a City supporter reading that news with a derby at Old Trafford coming up. Your striker’s preparation was suddenly a national talking point.
Balotelli later disputed the version that made him responsible. Speaking through City’s website, he said the incident involved friends and insisted he had done nothing. Whatever people made of his explanation, the fire itself had given the press another Balotelli story on the eve of the derby.
Sources — BBC reporting on the fire and Balotelli’s explanation to Manchester City
Who Made Balotelli’s Why Always Me Shirt?
Manchester City kitman Les Chapman printed the message. According to Chapman’s later account, Balotelli approached him on the Monday before the match and asked for something to go on his compression shirt.
Chapman ruled out anything offensive or controversial. A couple of suggestions failed that test. Then Balotelli came up with “Why always me?”
That timing matters. The conversation took place days before the bathroom fire. The slogan was already waiting for its moment when the weekend’s headlines arrived.
You can see why the two events became inseparable in people’s memories. A footballer spends Saturday in the news because of fireworks at his house, then scores on Sunday with a question about why he gets so much attention. The sequence almost edits itself.
Sources — Manchester City’s account of Chapman’s recollection and the Premier League’s shirt story
The Goal That Gave the Phrase Its Stage
In the 22nd minute at Old Trafford, James Milner found Balotelli, who guided a low finish beyond David de Gea.
Then came the pause.
Balotelli stood and revealed the shirt. There was something wonderfully direct about it. Thousands of people in the ground, television cameras fixed on him, and a question printed across his chest for everyone to read.
The match kept getting worse for United. Jonny Evans was sent off after fouling Balotelli early in the second half. Balotelli added his second, Sergio Agüero scored, and a late City surge turned a derby defeat into a 6–1 humiliation.
Edin Džeko finished with two goals and David Silva scored the other. City supporters had a scoreline they would repeat for years. Balotelli had supplied its defining photograph.
Sources — Manchester City’s retrospective on the 6–1 derby and UEFA’s match report
What Did Why Always Me Mean?
Immediately after the match, Balotelli left room for interpretation. He told City’s website there were several reasons behind the message and invited people to work it out themselves.
He was more specific about the supporters. He thanked City fans for backing him through difficult moments and described his two goals at Old Trafford as his way of repaying them. He also said the shirt message was a one-off because repeating it would mean getting booked every week.
That mix is what makes the celebration worth remembering. There was the joke, the frustration with being a constant subject of attention, and the confidence required to carry a prepared message into an away derby.
He still had to score before anyone could see it.
Source — Balotelli’s post-match comments
Why Football Still Remembers It
Plenty of players have revealed messages beneath their shirts. Balotelli gave his an audience at exactly the right moment.
For United supporters, that sky-blue kit belongs to an afternoon they would rather forget. For City supporters, it brings back the away end, the growing disbelief, and the pleasure of watching the scoreboard become increasingly ridiculous.
For everyone else, there is Mario, standing still while the rest of football tries to explain him.
Three words. One derby. Enough material for years of pub conversations.
Read more football stories from Saturdays Football
New releases
Shop all